Don’t Believe the Hype: Positive Implications of Greek Membership
The AFA (Association of Fraternity/Sorority Advisors) conference is happening right now (11/28/12) in Indianapolis. There are great programs on expansion, creating change, advising local organizations, restorative justice, masculinity and feminism, social justice and other great topics. What there aren’t are any programs like the one I’m going to propose for next year. “Apologize for nothing: addressing the negative impressions of Greek life without accepting them.”
An article in the Michigan Review details the results of the research done by James Turner at UVA who, after examining the mortality rates of 1150 schools found that for every 100,000 students there were just over 6 suicides and just under 5 alcohol deaths. (Note: They say “alcohol-related traffic deaths” in the article so my rephrasing may be misleading. If, as is likely, they specifically mean these types of deaths then when you add alcohol poisoning and the other alcohol deaths then I would imagine they eclipse the suicide rate. Since the gist of the article is that suicide is the #1 cause of death for college students, that wouldn’t make sense. I’ve therefore made the assumption that they mean “alcohol” deaths.) This got me to thinking about the things I used to discuss with my colleagues on the student crisis teams, and the impact being Greek has on the at-risk students. Since I’m not in grad school, I’m not going to do actual research studies (although if you do want a great thesis topic, feel free) but I thought I would post my thoughts and invite anyone who knows more to comment.
- Alcohol/dependency issues. I think there’s no doubt that Greeks have more students that are assessed in the “dependent” range for alcohol than their non-Greek counterparts. I do not know if the same is true for drugs, but I assume that it would actually be drug dependent. For example, I would not be surprised to hear that Greeks smoke more weed, but I would be surprised if they did more psychedelics or abused more pain medication. That being said, they drugs they do use may make them higher users of “drugs” in general. WINNER: Non-Greeks. That being said, I would be REALLY interested in comparing the alcohol consumption and drug use on campuses without Greek life (e.g. Bowdoin, Brandeis, Middlebury) with schools that have Greek life. I suspect that the actual consumption rates would be similar and in which case I’d have to say “Tie,” but I can’t prove that.
- Depression/Suicide. I think that Greeks are clearly the winners here. No matter how you feel about the types of connections people make in their fraternity/sorority, the fact remains that once you join these organizations you are rarely alone. You are usually sharing meals and running in the same social circles as a large group of people you like, so I would expect that there is a lot more “dude, what the f*#k is wrong with you” type of intervention than there would be in traditional male relationships. I can actually think of dozens of examples of fraternity men and sorority women supporting their brothers and sisters through disease, parental death, and other situations, and have heard from students directly that they wouldn’t have “made it through” without their brothers or sisters. WINNER: Greeks!
- Violence (non-dating): When you hear of a student writing manifestos, buying guns, or doing other crazy stuff that necessitates a threat assessment, it is almost never a member of a fraternity or sorority. In fact, find me one example without the word “loner” attached to the description of the student and I’ll be stunned. WINNER: Greeks!
- Inter-Personal Violence (e.g. sexual assault, dating violence, stalking.) I think the literature makes it pretty clear that Greeks have a higher incident rate for sexual assault (both as perpetrator and victim) but I would bet that stalking is lower mostly because of the ease of intervention both for the perpetrator (“dude! Let it go.”) and the victim (“That guy’s a freak. I’m taking you to the police.”) (That bet is based in nothing, so please feel free to correct me with actual data.) At schools with Greek life I’d have to probably say WINNER: Non-Greeks, but again the difference is narrow (and when you compare numbers of actual students I’ll bet there are more INCIDENTS among non-Greeks) and where there is no Greek life I would be interested to know once again about the actual incident rates to see if there are fewer per capita.
- Missing Students. Students occasionally get fed up and “disappear” for a while, usually by staying with a friend or taking a small road trip of some kind. Usually a parent will then call campus police after not hearing from their kid and file a campus missing persons report which triggers a pretty specific (and potentially lengthy) administrative process. As with the depression/suicide category I would bet that there are many more of these among non-Greeks for the same reasons. WINNER: Greeks!
- Campus Retention and Graduation. This isn’t a crisis matter, but another big issue on campuses is retention. One of the biggest selling points I see on Greek Life websites is that membership in Greek organizations make a student more likely to complete their college degree. (see, for example http://arizonagreek.orgsync.com/benefits) WINNER: Greek life!
So what’s the point? College administrators are quick to point out the areas of Greek life where the members are higher risk than non-Greeks, but I can’t think of a single upper administrator who has stood up and said “While drinking may be a bigger problem in the Greek community, membership in a fraternity or sorority decreases the likelihood that a student will drop out, be overwhelmed with depression, or commit suicide.” I’m not saying that you have to be Greek to have a happy and healthy college experience, but I encourage all or you to challenge your administrators, newspaper editorials, or anywhere else that tries to polarize people into “Pro” or “Anti” Greek camps. Constantly remind everyone that the things that people use to vilify Greeks are also true for non-Greeks while the positive aspects of being Greek are not easily replicated in traditional residential situations. Schools push co-curricular involvement to get a student vested in the college and the college experience, but completely disregard these benefits so they can talk about “hazing” and “binge drinking”–like that occasional aspect of Greek life is the ONLY purpose of Greek life. It isn’t, and I encourage you to refuse to accept that it is.
NB: A few housekeeping notes:
1. Go to our website to know more about what we do and what we can offer. We are working on a separate site/section for student organizations, but the services are similar.
2. If you are in college (or recently graduated and can remember what you were like in college) please fill out our survey. It should only take you 3 minutes, but it will really help us.
3. We are raising funds to (hopefully) tour colleges around the country this spring. Go to http://tinyurl.com/CJCSpringTour to donate. Any amount helps (especially since we have no donors at this point.)
5. I think the photo is Kent State Greeks. Completely snagged off the internet without permission. 🙂